How to Choose the Best Peanut Butter for Your Dog

How to Choose the Best Peanut Butter for Your Dog

Peanut butter is a beloved snack for humans and dogs alike, but not all peanut butters are created equal. It’s important to consider what makes up the ingredients in peanut butter when selecting one that’s safe and healthy for your pup. 

Let’s discuss what peanut butter best suits your furry friend and which types should be avoided.

What Makes a Good Peanut Butter?

It’s essential to find peanut butter that contains only simple, wholesome ingredients such as peanuts, salt, and maybe a sweetener such as honey or molasses. Avoid any kind of added sugar or preservatives, as these can cause health issues in dogs over time. 

Natural peanut butters with no added oil are often the most healthful option as they don’t contain any unhealthy fats or cholesterol. Additionally, look out for xylitol on the ingredient list, as it can be toxic to dogs if ingested in large amounts.

Pro Tip: Always check for xylitol in the ingredient list. It’s a sweetener that can be toxic to dogs.

How Much Peanut Butter is Too Much?

Like humans, moderation is key when feeding your pup peanuts or peanut butter. Dogs should never consume more than about one teaspoon of peanut butter per day, depending on their size—any more than that can lead to weight gain and other digestive problems over time. 

If you plan to use peanut butter as a treat while training your dog, opt for low-calorie varieties with fewer added sweeteners to limit their calorie intake during the day.

Recommended Brands for Your Dog

After thorough research and consultations with veterinarians, the following brands are vet-approved for their quality and safety:

Jif Natural Peanut Butter: Made with Organic Peanuts, No Added Sugars

Known for its clean ingredient list, Jif Natural uses only organic peanuts and avoids added sugars, making it a wholesome choice for your canine companion.

Skippy Natural Super Chunk: Low in Sodium, High in Protein

Skippy Natural Super Chunk offers low sodium levels and a high protein content. This makes it a nutritious pick for active or training dogs.

Lily’s Peanut Butter: Available in Philippine Markets, No Harmful Additives

Popular in the Philippines, Lily’s Peanut Butter offers a locally available option free from harmful additives, meeting the needs of health-conscious pet owners in the region.

Which Types Should I Avoid?

When looking at different brands of peanut butter, avoid those made with hydrogenated oils as they contain trans fats, which have been linked to obesity and heart disease in humans and pets alike. 

Also, avoid “low fat” varieties that replace healthy fats with sugar, artificial sweeteners, or other fillers that offer little nutritional value while potentially causing digestive upset in some dogs. 

Finally, avoid giving your pup any processed nut products such as salted nuts or trail mix containing dried fruit—these snacks can quickly get stuck in their throats or cause intestinal blockages if consumed whole.


It’s essential to read labels carefully when selecting good-quality peanut butter for your pup. Look out for healthy ingredients like peanuts, salt, and natural sweeteners like honey or molasses – anything else may provide little nutritional value while potentially being harmful if consumed in large amounts over time. 

Most importantly, though – remember moderation! A teaspoon per day should be plenty, so use it sparingly throughout the week as an occasional treat! 

With some careful consideration and research, you’ll be able to find the perfect brand of peanut butter for your pet’s needs!

Do you have a favorite brand that your dog loves? Share it with us in the comments below!

First Time Pet Parents, Food
grab a Barepets bare
doggy bag
Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop
Apply Coupon
Available Coupons
bareparent20 Get 20% off New customers can avail 20% off their first order.
Unavailable Coupons
freesample Get 100% off Get 1 free sample for FREE (dry or wet) when your order is over 800 PHP.